Lists Tech

10 Casting Decisions That Hurt The Show (And 10 That Saved It)

Say what you’ll about Two And A Half Males, and loads of its critics, detractors, followers, and forged members have; however the present lasted for over a decade. 262 episodes that may stay on endlessly in syndication and earn cash in perpetuity for everybody concerned within the collection. Like most conventional sitcoms, the premise is straightforward. A lately divorced, straight-laced unhappy sack and his younger impressionable son strikes in together with his devil-may-care, hedonistic jingle-writing brother.

Because of the very a lot publicized backstage and off-screen shenanigans of the collection’ unique star, Charlie Sheen, the present has to pivot huge time and turn into a barely much less debauchery-filled collection. However the void left by Sheen’s departure was full of a endless relentless collection of storylines that principally stored Alan turning into increasingly of s sniveling idiot.

In the meantime, Sheen’s alternative, Walden Schmidt at first appeared to have a coronary heart and was simply naive, however he too received corrupted by this motley crew of characters that he was surrounded by. Over the course of the present, there have been all types of stunt casting and visitor stars who rolled into Charlie Harper’s Malibu seashore home. Again when the present began, networks nonetheless cared about sweeps week. Typically the casting selection was an impressed welcome addition that made for a couple of memorable episodes, and others have been a little bit of a head-scratcher.

For higher or worse, whether or not it was for one present, or they have been a reoccurring forged member, listed here are 10 Casting Decisions That Hurt Two And A Half Males (And 10 That Saved It).

Proceed scrolling to maintain studying

Click on the button under to start out this text in fast view

Amber Tamblyn in Two and a Half Men

Begin Now

20 Hurt – Amber Tamblyn

Amber Tamblyn in Two and a Half Men

When the present’s eleventh season started, Amber Tamblyn was forged as Charlie’s long-lost illegitimate daughter, Jenny. Whereas the younger acclaimed actress did a serviceable job, it was clear that creator Chuck Lorre and the remainder of the writers have been struggling in the course of the previous few seasons of the present.

It was what loads of sitcoms do when the lead leaves, attempt to plug the void any which approach you possibly can. Kutcher might solely achieve this a lot as Walden with out turning into a clone of Charlie Harper. May as nicely create a long-lost member of the family to be that clone. The apparent ploy simply meant the collection was on its final legs.

19 Saved – Ashton Kutcher

Ashton Kutcher and Jon Cryer in Two and a Half Men

When the Martians got here to say their tiger blood-laden favourite son, Charlie Sheen; it was a meltdown of catastrophic, seldom seen earlier than proportions. Sheen’s feedback and conduct turned the laughing inventory of Hollywood and had loads of his buddies nervous about him. However most significantly, it put the way forward for the collection unsure.

Then Chuck Lorre introduced that the present will proceed, speculations abound as to what the artistic group would do – recast Charlie? Usher in one other brother? Invent an entire new character? When Ashton Kutcher was introduced to take over, we knew we’d have a a lot totally different present on our palms. Kutcher introduced a unique sort of sensibility to the present and the injection of latest non-Martian blood helped it chug alongside for a number of extra seasons.

18 Hurt – Judy Greer

Judy Greer’s comedic sensibilities are fantastically twisted – simply together with her on Archer. However she was wasted on Males, not as soon as however twice. Sitcoms typically forged actors a number of occasions in a number of roles. However they’re often appearing in small roles. Greer was forged and recast in two totally different however pretty necessary supporting roles.

In each of them, she was intoxicated. First, she performed Herb’s youthful sister who had a factor for Charlie. Then, she performed Walden’s ex-wife, Bridget. Whereas Myra may need some longevity had she not been written off the collection, Bridget would continually act like Walden’s mom and zap humor out of any scene she was in.

17 Saved – Charlie Sheen

Positive, he was the primary individual forged on the present, however what an impressed selection! Keep in mind the idea – he’s enjoying a carefree hedonistic jingle author. Whereas Sheen didn’t write jingles for a dwelling, the dangerous boy actor was recognized for his get together boy, wild youngster conduct.

The character was written with him in thoughts. Casting anybody else would have been an enormous detriment to the present. It won’t have lasted the eight seasons it did with another person enjoying Charlie.

16 Hurt – Mimi Rogers

In the course of the present’s last 4 years, a litany of latest characters was launched to modify up the format of the collection. Mimi Rogers performed Robin, Walden’s mom. Just like Evelyn, she would do questionable issues to and for her son. It was simply one other rehash of an previous character’s traits.

Fortunately, we didn’t need to endure too many episodes together with her. If you’re written to have raised your son alongside a monkey for science, it’s often a transparent indication that the writers aren’t making an attempt very exhausting anymore.

15 Saved – Holland Taylor

As Evelyn Harper, probably the most conniving mom that ever lived, Holland Taylor was devilishly pleasant to observe. Her banter with each Alan and Charlie we’re often scene-stealing highlights. However she wasn’t all the time the right mom for the position. Because the pilot was gearing up, one other well-known actress had been forged.

Blythe Danner was the unique Evelyn. The actress definitely had the chops to play mamma Harper. However the actress additionally tried to take over the set, making “suggestions” wherever she might. The producers recast the half and Taylor can be an integral a part of the present’s material.

14 Hurt – Brooke D’Orsay

Walden Schmidt was a rich man who received mountains of cash and loads of individuals who know who he’s. So, when he meets Kate, an aspiring dressmaker and she or he truly does not know who he’s, Walden’s immediately smitten. As an alternative of showing himself, he acted like a poor man, Sam Wilson; earlier than lastly revealing himself.

Between the character and the actress, Brooke D’Orsay, the entire relationship didn’t really feel real in any respect, and never as a result of Walden wasn’t being trustworthy. There was simply no chemistry between the 2 characters.

13 Saved – Jane Lynch

A younger youngster on the coronary heart of a divorce may want somebody to speak to in addition to their mother and father, or womanizing uncle. Jake began seeing Dr. Linda Freeman, a toddler psychologist. Afterward, she would additionally begin treating Charlie, Alan, and later, Walden.

She usually performed the straight man to the primary characters, once they wanted a sounding board. Mixed together with her no-nonsense method of seeing proper by way of all of them, Jane Lynch owned the half and like all nice visitor star made every look memorable.

12 Hurt – Ashton Kutcher

Sure, you’re studying that appropriately. Ashton Kutcher was capable of save the collection by being forged as Walden Schmidt. However the complete collection was not higher off for it. Sitcoms, by their very definition, are nearly the identical gags and yuks each week, only a totally different story. Kutcher being forged immediately modifications the state of affairs.

There wasn’t actually any selection – both forged a brand new lead or finish the present and put a number of forged and crew out of labor. Kutcher knew he’d be sending numerous followers to their remotes to vary the channel. By the character of his casting, the present inevitably modified.

11 Saved – Graham Patrick Martin

The older Jake received, the dumber he received too. Maybe in the event you cane from the identical ridiculous state of affairs he got here from, you may be worse off for it too. The collection stored enjoying him as your stereotypical stoner, slacker teenager. He would ultimately want a pal to have shenanigans with.

Graham Patrick Martin performed Lyndsay’s son Eldridge on the collection previous couple of seasons. He gave Jake somebody his personal age to narrate to, and the pairing turned the present’s personal model of idiotic duos like Wayne and Garth, or Beavis and Butthead.

10 Hurt – Miley Cyrus

Since one of many present’s stars had achieved all he might to tank the factor, may as nicely forged an actress who had seemingly executed all she might to tank her personal profession. The present has forged Miley Cyrus to play Missi – an eventual love curiosity for Jake. She got here into the collection as a household good friend of Walden’s.

Massive star castings on a collection will not be unusual in any respect, and in some methods,  Cyrus appeared proper up the present’s alley. However with out sufficient outstanding scenes or a narrative arc, it was stunt casting for the sake of it; which isn’t a great factor. Missi might have been performed by anybody.

9 Saved – Kathy Bates

In the course of the run of the present, Charlie all the time had delivered not-so-subtle hints that he needed his brother to give up mooching off of him and transfer out. He lastly received his want, however solely after he had handed away. Walden asks Alan to go away, who suffers a coronary heart assault because of the stress. In his hospital mattress, he meets Charlie’s ghost, performed by Kathy Bates.

Bates has the time of her life channeling Charlie Sheen and messing with Alan. It’s certainly one of her greatest performances, and among the best episodes of the Ashton Kutcher run (“Why We Gave Up Women”). She would win an award for her efficiency.

eight Hurt – Michael Bolton

When a joke is so very drained, it’s time to pack up the present and depart. That’s why when Michael appeared on Two And Half Males, it was time for the collection to Bolt(on). Walden was so wealthy that he was capable of rent Michael Bolton, not as soon as however twice to return to his help.

Each the Walden character and the present had sufficient clout to rent any superstar they needed, and the writers thought that Michael Bolton turning as much as sing his drained ballad, “When A Man Loves A Woman,” and mattress each Alan and Walden’s moms can be sitcom gold. It wasn’t in any respect. Simply one other demise knell within the collection’ coffin.

7 Saved – Jodi Lyn O’Keefe

In fact, Charlie wouldn’t care in any respect that he’s courting a wild demonic worshipping succubus who seeks to make use of Charlie as a human sacrifice for having a child with him. That’s a Tuesday for the womanizing jingle author. Alan and Jake have been terrified, however Charlie didn’t appear to thoughts the boils and marks that stored showing on his individual. The solely factor that stopped Isabella was her head witch – Evelyn.

Ladies continually got here out and in of the seashore home. However Jodi Lyn O’Keefe enjoying Isabella was a stroke of casting genius – most males wouldn’t thoughts her condemning them to a lifetime of servitude. The episode additionally had one of many present’s funniest bits – Evelyn because the Depraved Witch and the boys have been the flying monkeys.

6 Hurt – Courtney Thorne-Smith

One would assume that even Alan wouldn’t be so depressed and down on his luck that he would date a lady who berates and ridicules Alan as a lot as his circle of relatives does. Then once more, most individuals are likely to gravitate in the direction of what they know.

Performed by Courtney Thorne-Smith, not solely was Lyndsay out of Alan’s league, she too was simply as depressing courting Alan as he was being made to really feel by her. Typically it’s simply humorous watching how a lot an individual may be belittled. That’s not woke-speak; that’s simply comedy 101.

5 Saved – Kelly Stables

When these characters are on our TVs weekly, after which day by day because of syndication; we sometimes need to and luxuriate in seeing them completely satisfied. Earlier than he became a full-on lecherous creep, Alan obtained to have somewhat little bit of happiness together with his secretary turned girlfriend Melissa.

Kelly Stables performed Melissa with the proper of bat crap zaniness that was wanted for the present. Even throughout their 9 million break-ups, she all the time appeared to know what can be greatest for Alan – which was often for him to cease being Alan.

four Hurt – Edan Alexander

Within the guide entitled “How To Sink A Sitcom,” please flip your books to web page 237, chapter 12 – Introducing A New Child. Reference Oliver on The Brady Bunch or Seven on Married…With Youngsters, a brand new child is nearly all the time dangerous for the present. In an virtually act of defiance, Males did that very factor.

Louis didn’t add a single factor to the ultimate season of the present. The actor, Edan Alexander didn’t convey something to the position both, however maybe he wasn’t imagined to. The complete remaining season was one lengthy dangerous joke about Alan and Walden pretending to be lovers simply to undertake the child who doesn’t even present up within the finale, which is one lengthy rag on Charlie Sheen.

three Saved – Carl Reiner

Comedy pioneer Carl Reiner provides to absolutely anything he’s part of. To this era, he’s greatest referred to as Saul within the Ocean’s Eleven movie collection. However for an actual schooling on how humorous the man is, go verify he and Mel Brooks’ comedy album 2000-Yr-Previous Man.

Two And A Half Males would make use of Reiner now and again by casting him as Marty Pepper, a retired TV producer, who’s courting Evelyn and all the time tried to supply fatherly recommendation to Charlie and Alan, and later Alan and Walden; usually to terrible outcomes.

2 Hurt – Jennifer Bini Taylor

Jennifer Bini Taylor the actress is statuesque and delightful. As Chelsea, bodily, she had every thing Charlie would need in a lady. Emotionally although, that is Charlie Harper, probably the most disconnected individuals in sitcom historical past. The solely purpose we knew he beloved Chelsea, is as a result of he informed us.

However there was by no means any actual chemistry between Taylor and Sheen. A part of the joke is that she received alongside higher with Alan. Maybe she ought to have dated Alan and the jokes ought to have been how Charlie was insanely jealous.

1 Saved – Ryan Stiles

For those who ever need to torture somebody by making them chuckle themselves to dying – you’d have good luck strapping them down and forcing them to take heed to Ryan Stiles on episodes of Whose Line Is It Anyway? The man is laugh-a-second hysterical on the present. On Males, he was simply nearly as good, enjoying Herb, Judith’s second husband.

His comedic styling match the present properly, not solely due to how he performed off of Charlie and Alan, however due to how properly a lot of the viewers knew his comedic timing.

What do you consider these casting selections on Two and a Half Males? Tell us within the feedback!

!perform(f,b,e,v,n,t,s)
if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=perform() n.callMethod?
n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments);
if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n;n.push=n;n.loaded=!zero;n.model=’2.zero’;
n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!zero;
t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];
s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window, doc,’script’,
‘https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js’);
fbq(‘init’, ‘297467373958238’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);
if((window.location.href.indexOf(“utm_source”)!=-1))
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘ViewContent’);

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.10”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.10”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));