Lists Tech

10 Superhero Sequels That Became Massive Hits (And 10 That Completely Flopped)

The superhero style has by no means been extra common, with Avengers: Infinity Warfare turning into the fourth highest grossing film of all time in 2018. The Marvel film machine has helped to raise the style to new heights, which signifies that even obscure superheroes and supervillains have an opportunity at hitting the silver display.

The angle in the direction of superhero films hasn’t all the time been so constructive, nevertheless. The present crop of superhero films has the good thing about superb visible results know-how and a vocal Web fanbase that may promote them to the ends of the Earth with free promoting on social media, which was one thing that did not exist earlier than the ’00s.

The query now’s how lengthy will this love of superhero films final? The serialized nature of comedian books has ensured that DC and Marvel have sufficient materials to make lots of of films utilizing their hottest characters, however there’s all the time the danger of diminishing returns with sequels, particularly when there are solely so many iconic storylines and villains to go round. There is perhaps a whole lot of villains within the Batman canon, however most individuals will solely pay to see a number of of them in a film.

There have been loads of occasions when a superhero sequel has excelled and introduced their franchise to new ranges of fame, whereas others have tanked so horribly that they’ve pressured a personality into cinematic hibernation.

We’re right here as we speak to see which superhero sequels managed to exceed the expectations laid down by their predecessors and which of them dropped the ball on the field workplace – from the Darkish Horse character that turned a breakout star to the superhero film that tanked the style for a number of years.

Listed here are the 10 Superhero Sequels That Became Massive Hits (And 10 That Completely Flopped).

Proceed scrolling to maintain studying

Click on the button under to start out this text in fast view

Begin Now

20 Hit: Hellboy II: The Golden Military > Hellboy

The Hellboy identify might not maintain as a lot worth as a Batman or an Iron Man, however the first Hellboy managed to be a shock success with each critics and the mainstream viewers. The unique Hellboy film introduced in $99 million on the field workplace, which was spectacular for a movie based mostly on a comparatively unknown license. Hellboy II: The Golden Military managed to be much more spectacular, because it introduced in $160 million on the field workplace and was much more of successful with the critics. It was additionally nominated for an Academy Award for Greatest Make-up, although it misplaced to The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. 

The spectacular take of Hellboy II: The Golden Military did not assist the franchise earn funding for a 3rd film, which was one thing that languished for years, as Guillermo Del Toro was busy with different tasks and there all the time appeared to be hassle buying money to fund the manufacturing.

19 Flop: Batman V Superman: Daybreak Of Justice > Justice League

Batman v Superman: Daybreak of Justice is a polarizing film to make certain, however in the event you take a look at it from a cynical perspective, then it by no means wanted to be good within the first place. The unfavourable crucial reception to Daybreak of Justice did not cease it from bringing in $873 million dollars on the field workplace, which simply proves how a lot marquee worth the Batman and Superman names maintain when paired up collectively.

You possibly can solely make dangerous films for therefore lengthy earlier than there’s a backlash, which turned out to be the destiny of Justice League. Justice League introduced in $657 million on the field workplace, which was a step down from Daybreak of Justice and certain did not usher in a lot revenue, contemplating the pricey reshoots that the film underwent. It was additionally embarrassing for the DCEU that their equal to The Avengers could not even beat Thor: Ragnarok in ticket gross sales.

18 Hit: Captain America: The Winter Soldier > Captain America: The First Avenger

Those that noticed Captian America: The First Avenger in 2011 would by no means have guessed how superb the sequels can be. Captain America: The First Avenger was thought-about to be the blandest of the primary part of Marvel Cinematic Universe films, even when it wasn’t as outright horrible as Iron Man 2. The film would earn a good $370 million on the field workplace.

Captain America: The Winter Soldier was an enormous step up in high quality from the unique and managed to show Captain America into one of the fascinating members of the Avengers. The viewers reacted to this enchancment bu turning out in droves, which helped The Winter Soldier earn $714 million on the field workplace.

17 Flop: Superman II > Superman III

Superman and Superman II have been shot virtually concurrently, however the latter film suffered a whole lot of setbacks because of the success of the previous, as a mess of lawsuits and a studio making an attempt to exert higher management led to Superman II being lower than what it might have been.

Superman II might have had a variety of points, nevertheless it nonetheless managed to usher in $190 million on the field workplace, which was nonetheless a tremendous quantity, regardless that it was lower than the $300 million introduced in by Superman. Superman III noticed a far greater drop-off in numbers, because it solely introduced in $80 million on the field workplace, which was lower than half of what Superman II introduced in.

16 Hit: Thor: The Darkish World > Thor

Thor was the fourth film within the Marvel Cinematic Universe and it was the primary one to take the story past the boundaries of Earth. The success of Thor was an necessary second for the MCU, because it proved that they might flip weird ideas into money-making films. Thor introduced in $449 million on the field workplace, which was seen as an enormous win for the MCU and made The Avengers appear to be a protected guess, because the viewers was clearly hungry to see extra of the God of Thunder.

Thor: The Darkish World is not as extremely considered the unique and is seen as one of many blandest MCU films when it comes to its characters and story, however that did not cease it from exceeding the expectations laid down by its predecessor and bringing in $644 million on the field workplace.

15 Flop: Kick-Ass > Kick-Ass 2

The success of the superhero style in recent times led to some studios looking for out extra low-fi superhero comics to adapt, which had their very own built-in cult audiences and might be made for much less cash than a well-known DC/Marvel character. Kick-Ass was a shock hit in 2010 when it introduced a black comedy edge and new ranges of violence to the superhero style, because it earned $96 million on the field workplace.

Kick-Ass 2 was thought-about to be a step down from the unique film, with the Hit-Woman storyline seen by many as the one redeeming facet of the film. The polarizing crucial reception might have been liable for the movie solely taking in $60 million on the field workplace. The reception to Kick-Ass 2 could also be why we by no means noticed a Hit-Woman solo film or a correct sequel, because the franchise seems like it should be rebooted.

14 Hit: X-Males: The Final Stand > X2

The X-Males film collection has survived extra horrible entries than some other superhero film franchise round. It appears like the one factor that may take down the X-Males is the Disney/Fox merger, even when it is just for a brief time period. X2 was an enormous step up over the unique when it comes to high quality and continues to be considered one of many excessive factors of the collection. X2 additionally improved upon the unique’s field workplace take of $296 million by bringing in $407 million.

X-Males: The Final Stand was thought-about to be an enormous step down from X2 and disposed of a number of beloved characters in pointless methods. The long-lasting Darkish Phoenix Saga was completely botched and would not be touched once more for years. The tough important response to X-Males: The Final Stand did not cease it from enhancing on the field workplace take of its predecessor, nevertheless, because it introduced in $459 million.

13 Flop: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret Of The Ooze > Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III

The unique Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles film managed to combine parts from the favored cartoon collection with the darker comedian guide that it was based mostly on. It appears that evidently there was a backlash towards the darker moments within the first Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles film, because the sequel was significantly lighter in tone.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret of the Ooze was nearer to the TMNT cartoon collection when it comes to content material, however it nonetheless introduced in $78 million on the field workplace. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III had nothing to do with the TMNT cartoon, the unique comics, and even the opposite films. The film had a time journey plot that concerned the turtles touring to historic Japan and preventing an English dealer. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III solely introduced in $42 million on the field workplace and its launch was seen by many because the official finish of Turtlemania.

12 Hit: Logan > The Wolverine

Wolverine starred in three solo films all through the run of the X-Males films. The primary of those was X-Males Origins: Wolverine and is taken into account to be utter rubbish, The Wolverine was the second movie and it was thought-about to be common, if forgettable. The final solo Wolverine film was Logan, which was probably the most extremely regarded of the three films and gave Hugh Jackman an opportunity to send-off the character that had outlined his profession in a satisfying means.

The love for Logan could possibly be seen in its field workplace take, because it made $619 million on the field, regardless that it was an R-rated movie. This was an enormous step up from The Wolverine, which was a PG-13 film that introduced in $414 million on the field workplace.

11 Flop: Ghost Rider > Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance

Marvel had been making an attempt to make a Ghost Rider film for years, however the logistics of a fundamental character whose head was a flaming cranium meant that any Ghost Rider movie was going to be costly. We did not see a Ghost Rider film till 2007, with Nicolas Cage starring within the lead position. Ghost Rider acquired horrible evaluations, however it nonetheless managed to usher in $228 million on the field workplace, seemingly based mostly on the cool design of the character alone.

Ghost Rider’s superior look might solely maintain the franchise operating for therefore lengthy, as Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance solely introduced in $132 million on the field workplace. The evaluations for the sequel have been even worse than these of the unique Ghost Rider, with many criticizing Nicolas Cage’s efficiency as one of many worst elements of the film.

10 Hit: Batman Perpetually > Batman Returns

The Superman films turned much less critical over time, which was one of many essential explanation why the collection stored making much less cash. The identical wasn’t true for the Batman films that got here later… at the least not till the ultimate installment. Batman Returns was criticized for its darkish tone, which was thought-about by many to be an excessive amount of for a PG-13 film. These criticisms did not cease it from incomes $266 million on the field workplace, although, however this was a step down from the field workplace take of the unique Batman, which introduced in $411 million.

Batman Ceaselessly shifted focus to a extra family-friendly tone and was extra colourful than its predecessors. The critics weren’t followers of this new path, however that did not cease Batman Perpetually from bringing in $336 million on the field workplace, which was an enchancment on the cash introduced in by Batman Returns. 

9 Flop: The Crow > The Crow: Metropolis Of Angels

There are possible many followers of The Crow who aren’t conscious that it was based mostly on a comic book guide. The Crow made $50 million on the field workplace, which was an enormous hit relative to its finances, however it discovered much more success on house media and would earn an enormous cult following. The Crow starred Brandon Lee, who sadly succumbed to a gunshot wound that was by accident inflicted on the set.

You’d assume that the passing of Lee would be sure that no sequels to The Crow would ever be produced. Nevertheless, the film was profitable sufficient for an try and be made. The Crow: Metropolis of Angels was savaged by critics and solely introduced in $17 million on the field workplace.

eight Hit: Thor: Ragnarok > Thor: The Darkish World

Thor: The Darkish World introduced in a powerful $644 million on the field workplace, however it did not depart a lot of an impression on the followers. The occasions of The Darkish World virtually really feel like an afterthought within the grand scheme of issues and it is exhausting to think about the film as something aside from filler.

Thor: Ragnarok was an enormous step up from its predecessor when it comes to its high quality and relevance to the general MCU. Thor might have had somewhat assist from the Hulk for his third film, however that does not diminish the truth that Thor: Ragnarok introduced in $854 million on the field workplace, which is a powerful quantity and certain exceeded Disney’s expectations.

7 Flop: The Masks > Son Of The Masks

The Masks is just like The Crow in that most individuals aren’t conscious of the truth that it is tailored from a comic book ebook. It definitely wasn’t marketed as such when it was first launched. The Masks was a comedic tackle the superhero style, with a important character who had the powers of a dwelling cartoon character. The Masks helped Jim Carrey and Cameron Diaz grow to be big stars and introduced in $351 million on the field workplace.

The success of The Masks made a sequel appear inevitable, but it by no means received off the bottom. Jim Carrey had little interest in reprising the position. In 2005, a sequel to The Masks was lastly launched, despite the fact that it had virtually nothing to do with the unique. Son of the Masks was savaged by critics upon launch and it solely managed to usher in $59 million on the field workplace, which meant that it did not even recoup its manufacturing price range.

6 Hit: Captain America: Civil Conflict > Captain America: The Winter Soldier

Captain America: The Winter Soldier was an enormous step up from the unique, however nobody might have anticipated the way it was establishing a film that was going to be even higher. Captain America: Civil Conflict is greatest described because the film that Age of Ultron ought to have been. It lastly gave followers the prospect to see two groups of superheroes preventing one another in what continues to be probably the most spectacular sequence within the MCU.

Captain America: The Winter Soldier introduced in a powerful $714 million on the field workplace, however Captain America: Civil Conflict introduced in $1.153 billion dollars, making it the very best grossing film of 2016.

5 Flop: X-Males: Days Of Future Previous > X-Males: Apocalypse

X-Males: Days of Future Previous was the long-awaited adaptation of probably the most in style X-Males storylines of all time. The small print have been modified within the transition (most notably with Wolverine being the one despatched into the previous as an alternative of Kitty Pryde), however the concept of a member of the X-Males going again in time to stop a future the place mutants are virtually worn out stays the identical. X-Males: Apocalypse botched the arrival of some of the fashionable villains within the franchise, with the grandiose Apocalypse changed with a boring man in blue.

X-Males: Days of Future Previous introduced in $747 million on the field workplace, whereas X-Males: Apocalypse solely introduced in $543 million. The smaller take of X-Males: Apocalypse in comparison with its price range and promoting value led many to marvel if the film had even introduced in a revenue and whether or not it ought to be referred to as a flop.

four Hit: The Darkish Knight > Batman Begins

Batman Begins was a serviceable film that helped to differentiate Christopher Nolan and Christian Bale’s new tackle the character. The aim of the movie was to distance this new Batman from each the campy Adam West model of the character and the cartoonish farce that the earlier Batman film collection had descended into. Batman Begins succeeded in establishing a brand new Batman, however it solely introduced in $375 million on the field workplace.

The Darkish Knight continues to be one of the highly-regarded superhero films of all time and it helped to determine Heath Ledger as the brand new face of the Joker, even when he would solely ever be given one probability to play him in a film. The Darkish Knight would usher in $1.005 billion on the field workplace and would guarantee that you’d see a Joker in a nurse outfit at each Halloween social gathering for the foreseeable future.

three Flop: Superman III > Superman IV: The Quest For Peace

The Christopher Reeve Superman films are matched solely by the unique 4 Batman films when it comes to a downward spiral of high quality. The unique Superman continues to be a tremendous film to behold and the sequel had moments of greatness in-between all the studio mandated dangerous concepts.

Superman III had some horrible concepts, nevertheless it nonetheless managed to usher in $80 million on the field workplace, which meant that it was nonetheless successful, regardless of the crucial reception. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace managed to someway be even worse than its predecessor and continues to be considered one of many worst superhero films of all time. It was a tragic finish to what began out as probably the most promising superhero film collection of all time, as The Quest for Peace solely introduced in $36 million on the field workplace.

2 Hit: Iron Man three > Iron Man 2

There are some Marvel films which are thought-about to be much less fascinating than others, however the one outright blemish on the MCU’s document (for those who ignore the TV exhibits) is Iron Man 2, which is extensively considered the worst film within the franchise.

Iron Man three managed to redeem the solo Iron Man films with a shocking twist involving the villain who managed to someway keep away from being spoiled earlier than the discharge of the film and by truly creating the character of Tony Stark in fascinating methods. The enhancements to the Iron Man films could be seen within the numbers, as Iron Man 2 introduced in $623 million on the field workplace, whereas Iron Man three introduced in $1.215 billion.

1 Flop: Batman Ceaselessly > Batman And Robin

Batman Begins will not be as extremely considered its successors, however it must be recommended for serving to to determine Batman as a field workplace draw once more after he starred in a film that nearly tanked the style. Batman Perpetually might have had a lighter tone than Batman Returns, however it was nonetheless recognizable as a Batman film.

The campiness of the characters and story in Batman & Robin might have given the Adam West Batman present a run for its cash and it appeared one million miles away from the world established within the unique Tim Burton Batman film. Batman Perpetually introduced in $336 million on the field workplace, whereas Batman & Robin solely introduced in $238 million. These numbers have been respectable for the time, however the film managed to tug down your complete style for a number of years and stored Batman out of the films for nearly a decade.

Are there some other superhero sequels that turned large hits or full flops? Tell us within the feedback!

if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=perform() n.callMethod?
s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window, doc,’script’,
fbq(‘init’, ‘297467373958238’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘ViewContent’);

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “//”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “//”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));