- 1 Which Low cost Synology NAS do you have to Purchase? DS119j, DS218j or DS418j
- 2 Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j – Worth for Cash
- 3 Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j – Design
- 4 Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j – Hardware
- 5 Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j- Software program
- 6 Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j- Verdict
- 7 Want Recommendation on Knowledge Storage from an Professional?
Which Low cost Synology NAS do you have to Purchase? DS119j, DS218j or DS418j
For many who are looking to buy their very first NAS drive, or are simply on the lookout for a easy community backup to help their present NAS server, it may be a bit complicated. Synology has made efforts to separate their vary of NAS server drives into totally different classes, in an effort to differentiate which one is best suited for various purposes. Very early on it turns into clear that the Synology J collection is probably the most value-efficient vary of units of their portfolio, nevertheless, they’ve a really comparable worth and apart from numerous Exhausting Drive bays, it may be very arduous to decide on the perfect finances NAS in 2019. So, we’ve got determined to match the Synology DS119J 1-Bay, the Synology DS218J 2-Bay and the oldest of the three, the Synology DS418J NAS.
Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j – Worth for Cash
Since you need to purchase a price range/value efficient NAS answer, it is going to be an enormous consideration for a way a lot it is going to value. Though these three NAS drives are by far the bottom priced Synology NAS units you should purchase of their respective ranges, in comparison towards one another, the worth tag variations are fairly huge. In reality, within the bounce from 1-bay, to 2-bay and eventually to three-Bay, the worth virtually doubles every time! The Purpose for that is threefold.
- The variety of onerous drive bays inside requires a greater CPU every time to deal with the RAID and communication of customers to the bigger media
- A much bigger energy provider is required every time to help these drives
- A much bigger chassis is required to deal with the drives, in addition to improved strategies of cooling/air flow to make sure most operational temperatures
Most customers on a decent finances will need to appropriately divide their price range between NAS hardware and NAS Exhausting Drive storage (which must be bought individually). NAS Arduous drives are roughly £30-35 per Terabyte (utilizing Seagate Ironwolf NAS drives for instance), so you will want to issue this in. Though the DS119J is simply £90+, it will probably solely maintain 1 arduous drive, so you’ll both have to spend extra on a much bigger HDD (lose any RAID help too) or restrict your lengthy-time period storage. Alternatively, you should purchase the DS218J at £150+ and both unfold the price of storage throughout two HDD bays or simply populate the NAS with 1 onerous drive at first and add one other later.
Which leads me to advocate extremely that you simply purchase the Synology DS418J NAS as the most effective NAS for worth for cash. Though it’s by far the costliest NAS at £280+, you’ve the choice of four arduous drives and SIGNIFICANTLY higher hardware inside that the others (will talk about extra under). The clincher is just the very fact you possibly can add onerous drives over time, beginning with a small drive to start out and add greater and higher drives as you want over time. The DS218j and DS119j NAS each require you so as to add BIG exhausting drives initially so as to guarantee lengthy-time period storage and this finally ends up costing you extra in the long term.
WINNER – Synology DS418J NAS
You simply get alot extra on your cash. Additionally, it permits you to leverage the price of HDD and NAS Hardware a lot better general.
Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j – Design
Although all three Synology NAS is price range in worth, all three have adopted the Synology fashion very nicely certainly. NAS drives are designed to be left on for days, weeks and months at a time, so each passive and lively cooling is essential. All NAS function a number of panels of air flow and an lively rear cooling fan, nevertheless, though the DS119j and DS218j are very comparable (utilizing a close to equivalent white plastic chassis, non scorching-swap drives and a single plastic rear fan), the DS418j is a really totally different gadget certainly when it comes to design. All three function twin USB ports (with USB 2.zero on the DS119j) and all three NAS function the ventilated Synology emblem.
166 mm x 71 mm x 224 mm
10.04 W (entry)
5.01 W (arduous disk hibernation)
165 mm x 100 mm x 225.5 mm
17.48 W (entry)
7.03 W (exhausting disk hibernation)
184 mm x 168 mm x 230 mm
21.22 W (entry)
eight.97 W (arduous disk hibernation)
Right away, the DS119j and DS218j NAS are the extra discreet of the 2 NAS, with the 1-Bay and a couple of-Bay being slightly below 3cm (29mm in reality) totally different in width. Each use a plastic chassis which lowers operational noise significantly and each are very discreet when it comes to measurement. They even have very comparable energy consumption, regardless of their distinction in worth/measurement which is all the time a consideration for warmth era and lengthy-time period operating. The DS418j, then again, is far greater in each course, includes a moderately dated wanting chassis (appears like a 70s cooking equipment however in black) and is a mixture of metallic and plastic. As a lot as I need to reward them for the design high quality, there isn’t any escaping that the DS418j is the least engaging of the three, is greater, noisier and generates extra warmth (even regardless of these twin rear followers).
WINNER – The Synology DS218j NAS
Though it is rather just like the DS119j, it appears to do a a lot better job of taking advantage of that chassis design and makes delicate enhancements over the smaller NAS.
Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j – Hardware
When it comes to hardware, the DS119j, DS218j and DS418j have taken very totally different paths. We mentioned the surface chassis and so forth earlier, however (like many issues) it’s what inside that counts! With every worth/bay leap between them, the interior CPU energy, reminiscence storage and effectivity successfully doubles with every tier. See under:
Marvell Armada 3700 88F3720
Marvell Armada 385 88F6820
- three.5″ SATA HDD
- 2.5″ SATA HDD (with optionally available 2.5″ Disk Holder)
- three.5″ SATA HDD
- 2.5″ SATA HDD (with non-compulsory 2.5″ Disk Holder)
- 2.5″ SATA SSD (with elective 2.5″ Disk Holder)
- three.5″ SATA HDD
- 2.5″ SATA HDD
- 2.5″ SATA SSD
The CPU on the Synology DS119j is painfully low powered. Don’t be fooled by the very fact it’s a twin core, it’s painfully low powered and whilst a community backup drive, it nonetheless registers very low speeds certainly. Actually, all three NAS are twin core in design and the DS218j and DS418j are very comparable in clock velocity (1.3Ghz and 1.4Ghz). Nevertheless, the large, BIG factor to recollect is the very fact the DS218j makes use of a 32bit structure CPU and the DS418j makes use of a 64bit structure CPU. The distinction right here could be very, essential, as extra purposes will be capable of run on a 64bit processor, in addition to it operating smoother general because of it’s improved floating level. This level is additional enforced by the higher reminiscence current within the DS418j, in contrast with the opposite two. There’s twice as a lot RAM within the DS418j than the DS218j, in addition to 4x of the DS119j. However as soon as once more, it’s high quality that’s necessary right here – the DS418j makes use of quicker DDR4 reminiscence, whereas the DS119j and DS218j use DDR3.
WINNER – Synology DS418J NAS
It is extremely exhausting to disregard the quicker, extra environment friendly and succesful CPU on the DS418j NAS, in addition to the upper amount and high quality reminiscence included with this NAS.
Synology DS119j vs DS218j vs DS418j- Software program
As you’d anticipate, given the superior hardware featured on the Synology DS418j, it has a a lot greater protection of NAS software program within the Synology DiskStation Supervisor software program than the DS119j and DS218j. Nevertheless, although the DS418j is leaps forward of the Synology DS119j NAS, it is just fractionally higher when it comes to software program than the DS218J. The important thing benefits are solely these the place the extra two bays of storage play their half. Under are the important thing/common software program specs for the three NAS and the way they examine:
(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s);
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = ‘https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.11&appId=1158761637505872’;
(doc, ‘script’, ‘fb-jssdk’));